Charges Held in Methacton Teacher-Student Cyber Sex Case

Sean McCullough is facing criminal charges stemming from a sexual relationship he allegedly had with a 17-year-old student over text and Facebook.

All charges were upheld against former Methacton High School teacher Sean McCullough in a preliminary hearing before District Judge Cathleen Kelly Rebar on Thursday, Aug. 29.

McCullough, of the 100 block of Hunsicker Drive in Collegeville, faces several criminal charges including one count of Solicitation of Child Pornography, as was included by Montgomery County assistant district attorney Samantha Cauffman, captain of the , at the onset of the preliminary hearing.

The Corruption of Minors charge was reduced to a first-degree misdemeanor due to the time-period during which the charge would have applied.

McCullough, 43, has been accused of an inappropriate relationship of a sexual nature with a former Methacton High School student, whom he taught since her freshman year.

According to court documents, McCullough was also charged with:

  • Endangering Welfare of Children – Parent/Guardian/Other Commits Offense
  • Disseminating Explicit Sexual Material of Minors
  • Corruption of Minors
  • Photograph/Film/Depict on Computer Sex Act – Child
  • Possession of Child Pornography
  • Sexual Abuse of Children – Possession of Child Pornography
  • Criminal Use of Communication Facility

All of the charges against McCullough are felonies except for the Corruption of Minors charge.

According to the preliminary hearing testimony of Lower Providence Detective Michael Jackson (the case’s lead investigator), McCullough and the female student had engaged in sexual activity through numerous e-mails, Facebook messages and text messages from a period of June 2010 to July 25, 2010.

The female student was a minor during the alleged sexual activities. The woman, now 20, graduated from Methacton High School in 2010.

In the affidavit of probable cause, the female student reportedly denied having any physical contact with McCullough, but reportedly admitted to engaging in intimate behavior over private Facebook and text messages while she was still 17 years old.

Also in an interview with Jackson, McCullough reportedly admitted to engaging in sexual activity including "sex chats" through Facebook messages, mutual masturbation, and exchanging nude photographs, as well as kissing and fondling one another while the female student was still 17 years old.

During the preliminary hearing, McCullough's attorney, Stephen Geday, argued that the solicitation or dissemination of child pornography charge would not qualify, as the exchange of nude photos via a mobile device was hearsay, and would require original content. Furthermore, Geday challenged the Commonwealth’s charge of a sexual act of a child on photograph, film or as depicted on a computer, because no evidence has been produced to show that McCullough purposely directed the female student to provide such material.

“Does ‘depicted’ on a computer mean shown visually?” Geday asked, emphasizing that action on the computer was limited to “sex-chats.”

Rebar agreed that no evidence has been shown to indicate McCullough directed the female student to send the explicit material via a mobile device, but she also said that photographs sent through a mobile device could be uploaded and viewed on a computer.

Rebar also said that such prohibited photos or film may not need apply, given the explicit nature of the Facebook messages and other texts.

“The evidence is very clear to me, in his Facebook messages, that he directed her to perform certain acts, and did them himself, and that he depicted them very descriptively in his text, in his e-mails,” Rebar said. “There’s no question.”

Rebar further responded that the Commonwealth did not need to produce original content for a preliminary hearing. She also explained that the Commonwealth’s case is based on McCullough’s own statement to police, along with a “half-inch worth of e-mail” explicitly describing the sexual activities, as obtained by police via a search warrant.

At the end of the hearing, Rebar granted Geday’s request to limit McCullough’s restriction from Methacton High School to its grounds, as opposed to the previous 1-mile radius, as McCullough lives in reasonable proximity to the school and his offenses seem to be an isolated incident.

Geday also questioned if future contact would be permissible between McCullough and the female student. Per the bond arrangement, which was set at $50,000, McCullough is prohibited in initiating or receiving contact from the female student, including through third-party members, such as Facebook.

According to Cauffman, the female student has stated she has no desire to continue the relationship with McCullough at this time.

“He’s been this child’s teacher for all four years,” Cauffman said, during the preliminary hearing. 

She described their previous mentor relationship as damaged.

“These chats are horrendous,” Cauffman said.

McCullough did not testify at the hearing. He is scheduled to be arraigned in county court on Oct. 10 and currently remains free after posting the required 10% of his $50,000 bail.


Related Stories


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »