Shapiro, Richards Win Election to Board of Commissioners

Castor, Brown concede in Blue Bell; uncertainty over whether Castor will resume commish seat in January

The Montgomery County Board of Commissioners is headed for Democratic control.

Incumbent commissioner Bruce Castor, Jr. and his running mate Jenny Brown conceded the election shortly after 11 p.m. Tuesday to Democrats Josh Shapiro and Leslie Richards, who are now Commissioners-elect.

"Obviously, I'm disappointed," said Brown at the Montgomery County Republican Committee's election night party in Blue Bell. She expressed gratitude for the work done by the people who supported the Republican campaign.

Brown said she will continue to serve as Lower Merion Commissioner, where she has two years left on her term.

"I'm looking forward to getting back to my law practice," Brown said.

Castor, who led all candidates in votes in his 2007 election to the Board of Commissioners, was re-elected to the board as the minority member.

Despite finishing first in the 2007 election for the office, Castor is widely regarded as having been frozen out of county policy-making by the unofficial alliance of his fellow commissioners, Republican Jim Matthews—his one time running mate—and Democrat Joe Hoeffel. As the minority member of a Democrat-controlled Board of Commissioners, his position in that regard would seem unlikely to improve.

There was some doubt as to whether Castor would, in fact, be willing to return to his seat.

"That's a good question," Brown-Castor campaign spokesman Stephen O'Toole said late Tuesday when asked if Castor would continue as a commissioner in January. O'Toole said the county Republican Party would review the situation in the coming days.

"I'm hoping I'll finish fourth," Castor told the Philadelphia Inquirer, "but I'm afraid it will be third."

It was. Castor finished with 77,114 votes, more than 1,600 ahead of Brown.

Good night for Dems

The Shapiro-Richards victory capped a generally successful night for the Democratic Party in the county.

Democrats also won both seats up for grabs on the county's Court of Common Pleas, as Cheryl Austin and Richard Haaz defeated Republicans Dan Clifford and Maureen Coggins.

Incumbent Clerk of Courts Ann Thornberg Weiss held off a challenge by Lansdale-based attorney Moon Ahn, and Walter Hofman appeared to have very narrowly won re-election as county coroner over Republican challenger Gordon Clement.

Democrats also won the races for Prothonotary with William E. Donnelly losing out to Democrat Mark Levy; Recorder of Wills, with D. Bruce Hanes over Patricia A. Mosesso; and Treasurer, with Jason E. Salus topping Chuck Wilson.

County Republicans could claim some significant victories. Challenger Stewart Greenleaf, Jr., unseated sitting county controller Diane Morgan. Morgan was perhaps best known for filing a lawsuit against the sitting Board of Commissioners that alleged she was being denied the resources necessary to execute the duties of the office.

Sheriff Eileen Behr won her first election to the job after being appointed to the post by Governor Tom Corbett last spring to complete the term of deceased former Sheriff John Durante.

Nancy Becker held onto her job as the county's Recorder of Deeds, fending off a challenge by Democrat Linda Hee.

District Attorney Risa Ferman, a Republican, won another term in a race in which she was unopposed.

Marc Lombardi November 10, 2011 at 05:57 PM
Even Rush Limbaugh threatened to move a few times, but he's still here unfortunately.
Ruthiness November 10, 2011 at 07:03 PM
@Marc - my leaving is a promise - not a threat - leaving the entire STATE but not the country. I will enjoy from a distance, watching the government self-destruct with these two Dems in charge of the county. Buckle your seat belts everyone - gonna be a rough ride. And.. typical liberal - you don't like opposing voices so you seek to silence them or "make them go away". Tyrants like Stalin and Hitler had that same attitude... I choose to vote with my feet and leave a state which is going toward all out state control of the people - and I say that with a Republican governor and Republican controlled state legislature - so try and put me in a left vs right box now!
Marc Lombardi November 10, 2011 at 07:35 PM
Ruthiness: Where the heck am I trying to stifle your speech? I'm not making you do anything. You and your ilk (not Republicans, but the over-reactionary political diehards from BOTH sides who seem to think in nothing but extremes) goes into Chicken Little mode every time an election doesn't go your way. I've been voting since the day I turned 18 back in 1991, and I've never threatened to run away from somewhere because of one single election. Do what you want, say what you want. Doesn't mean I have to agree with you. Enjoy Kentucky...or Texas...or whatever state you're escaping to. And comparing me to Hitler & Stalin? I feel great about that! Some of those Tea Partiers compared Obama to Hitler, too. I'm moving up in the world.
Ruthiness November 10, 2011 at 08:33 PM
@Marc - the most extreme people are the ones who wish to control all of us - our everyday lives in the most minute ways - because this tiny group believes that we are causing our planet to get too warm. That is pretty extreme. In fact, it's a CULT. The green movement is identical to the Crusades and WILL lead again to the DARK AGES if people don't wake up. And Obama? He's more like Chairman Mao - the most murderous "social justice" tyrant on this planet
Marc Lombardi November 10, 2011 at 08:51 PM
Ruthiness: Do you believe in aliens?


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »